Key Points
At a more pragmatic level, one land route of President Xi Jinping’s legacy BRI passes through the Middle East. That makes it imperative for China to ensure the security of that route, which necessitates, in turn, that Beijing develop and maintain a close relationship with the region.
There is yet another reason for China to wish to enhance its relations with the countries of the Middle East: its treatment of its Muslim-majority Uighur population. If its economic policies and overall grand strategy are to succeed, the Chinese Communist Party needs to ensure that the entire Chinese population works with it to achieve those objectives and, once it does, to ensure that social differences do not threaten any newly-found power or economic status. It needs to ensure, consequently, that the Chinese population thinks and acts alike, adheres to the same social mores, speaks the same language and, importantly, places an adherence to the Party above all else. The Uighur people, being Muslim, ethnically Turkic and speaking their own language, do not fit those requirements, just as the Tibetan people do not. Beijing has, therefore, enacted repressive measures to force the Uighurs to comply with its diktat, including the incarceration of around a million Uighur citizens in prison camps that it euphemistically terms “re-education camps” or “vocational training centres”. It has also been alleged that China seeks to breed the Uighur people out of existence by encouraging them to marry Han Chinese. Given that, China feels it necessary to ensure that its version of events and its reasons for this state of affairs are made known to, and accepted by, the countries of the Middle East. That enhanced relationship would also be required to ensure that any action taken against China or its interests by Islamist groups or Uighur rebels would be condemned by the Muslim-majority countries of the Middle East.
While China may have its reasons for wishing to displace the US in the Middle East and to replace it, the issue is whether Beijing has the capacity to replace Washington there. A poll conducted last year by the Pew Research Centre found that in 38 countries, a median of 42 per cent found that the US is the world’s leading economy, while 32 per cent gave that title to China. Added to that, most countries of the Middle East have more investments in the US than they do China, which could be seen as an indication of their trust in the US economy, no matter its many problems, and their perception that the US remains the global financial hub, despite the rise of regional centres such as Shanghai. They would also be sharply aware that the global financial system is skewed in favour of the US, that the US remains the world’s technological leader and innovator and that, for all of its myriad failings, democracy is far more attractive to the business and commercial environments than authoritarianism. The average Middle Eastern person, moreover, is more likely to study in the US, to watch films made in the US, to visit the US and to speak English than to study in China, watch Chinese films, visit China or speak Mandarin.
No observer of Middle Eastern affairs, more importantly, sees any chance of China replacing the US as the region’s security guarantor. Whereas the US, for all its policy gaffes and military misadventures in the region, has involved itself in the Middle East and attempted to play the role of peacemaker, China prefers to not be involved in the politics of the region but to conduct business on a transactional basis, except when it makes political sense to do otherwise or when it perceives a decided advantage to itself. No matter that China has taken some minor steps to involve itself in Syria, the fact remains that those are of no real consequence in the greater scheme of things. Beijing’s approach to the politics of the Middle East is, in short, minimalist and out of all proportion to its business ventures there.
The Chinese commercial footprint in the Middle East is certainly growing, just as its overall presence is. Whether it will replace the United States in the region in the near to mid-term future is quite another matter.
*****
- The United States has had a geostrategic interest in the Middle East since the Second World War.
- That interest was based on its global aspirations as well as its energy dependence.
- It has, more recently, witnessed a diminution of political interest in the region as well as reduced dependence on Middle Eastern energy.
- That situation has caused concern among the rulers in the Middle East, who seek a security guarantor if the US were to withdraw from the region.
- China has various reasons for wishing to replace the US in the Middle East.
- Whether Beijing desires to achieve that goal, however, is uncertain.
At a more pragmatic level, one land route of President Xi Jinping’s legacy BRI passes through the Middle East. That makes it imperative for China to ensure the security of that route, which necessitates, in turn, that Beijing develop and maintain a close relationship with the region.
There is yet another reason for China to wish to enhance its relations with the countries of the Middle East: its treatment of its Muslim-majority Uighur population. If its economic policies and overall grand strategy are to succeed, the Chinese Communist Party needs to ensure that the entire Chinese population works with it to achieve those objectives and, once it does, to ensure that social differences do not threaten any newly-found power or economic status. It needs to ensure, consequently, that the Chinese population thinks and acts alike, adheres to the same social mores, speaks the same language and, importantly, places an adherence to the Party above all else. The Uighur people, being Muslim, ethnically Turkic and speaking their own language, do not fit those requirements, just as the Tibetan people do not. Beijing has, therefore, enacted repressive measures to force the Uighurs to comply with its diktat, including the incarceration of around a million Uighur citizens in prison camps that it euphemistically terms “re-education camps” or “vocational training centres”. It has also been alleged that China seeks to breed the Uighur people out of existence by encouraging them to marry Han Chinese. Given that, China feels it necessary to ensure that its version of events and its reasons for this state of affairs are made known to, and accepted by, the countries of the Middle East. That enhanced relationship would also be required to ensure that any action taken against China or its interests by Islamist groups or Uighur rebels would be condemned by the Muslim-majority countries of the Middle East.
While China may have its reasons for wishing to displace the US in the Middle East and to replace it, the issue is whether Beijing has the capacity to replace Washington there. A poll conducted last year by the Pew Research Centre found that in 38 countries, a median of 42 per cent found that the US is the world’s leading economy, while 32 per cent gave that title to China. Added to that, most countries of the Middle East have more investments in the US than they do China, which could be seen as an indication of their trust in the US economy, no matter its many problems, and their perception that the US remains the global financial hub, despite the rise of regional centres such as Shanghai. They would also be sharply aware that the global financial system is skewed in favour of the US, that the US remains the world’s technological leader and innovator and that, for all of its myriad failings, democracy is far more attractive to the business and commercial environments than authoritarianism. The average Middle Eastern person, moreover, is more likely to study in the US, to watch films made in the US, to visit the US and to speak English than to study in China, watch Chinese films, visit China or speak Mandarin.
No observer of Middle Eastern affairs, more importantly, sees any chance of China replacing the US as the region’s security guarantor. Whereas the US, for all its policy gaffes and military misadventures in the region, has involved itself in the Middle East and attempted to play the role of peacemaker, China prefers to not be involved in the politics of the region but to conduct business on a transactional basis, except when it makes political sense to do otherwise or when it perceives a decided advantage to itself. No matter that China has taken some minor steps to involve itself in Syria, the fact remains that those are of no real consequence in the greater scheme of things. Beijing’s approach to the politics of the Middle East is, in short, minimalist and out of all proportion to its business ventures there.
The Chinese commercial footprint in the Middle East is certainly growing, just as its overall presence is. Whether it will replace the United States in the region in the near to mid-term future is quite another matter.
*****


Share Your Comments
Only members can comment, Click here to sign up for free right now