Analysing the Links Between Climate Change and Non-State Armed Groups
Insurgency, Terrorism and Organised Crime in a Warming Climate
Analysing the Links Between Climate Change and Non-State Armed Groups
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Over the past ten years, both our understanding and awareness of the links between climate change and
security have increased tremendously. Today the UN, the EU, the G7 and an increasing number of states
have classified climate change as a threat to global and/or national security. However, the links between
climate change, conflict and fragility are not simple and linear. The increasing impacts of climate change
do not automatically lead to more fragility and conflict. Rather, climate change acts as a threat multiplier.
It interacts and converges with other existing risks and pressures in a given context and can increase the
likelihood of fragility or violent conflict. States experiencing fragility or conflict are particularly affected,
but also seemingly stable states can be overburdened by the combined pressures of climate change,
population growth, urbanization, environmental degradation and rising socio-economic inequalities.
Taking the state of play on the links between climate change and fragility as a starting point, this report
addresses the question of how the impacts of climate change are a contributing factor in the rise and
growth of NSAGs. Non-state armed groups are not a new phenomenon.
Today, however, we can observe an increasingly complex landscape of violent actors with a range of hybrid organisational structures, different agendas and different levels of engagement with society that set them apart from ‘traditional’ non-state actors and result in new patterns of violence. They operate on different levels, within or outside formal armed conflict and include youth and street gangs, criminal groups and organised crime as well
as highly professionalized terrorist groups such as Al Qaeda, ISIS, or Al Shabaab or militia providing
community security.
Four case studies that span the whole spectrum of NSAGs and patterns of violence, conflict and fragility
explore in depth the specific role NSAGs play in the complex dynamics of climate change and fragility and
try to identify how climate change acts as a risks multiplier in regards to NSAGs. These case studies
show that as the climate is changing, so too are the conditions within which NSAGs operate. The complex
risks arising from climate change, fragility and conflict can contribute to the emergence and growth of
NSAGs. This does not imply that there is a direct link between climate change and NSAG-related violence
and conflict. However, large-scale environmental and climatic change contributes to creating an environment
in which NSAGs can thrive and opens spaces that facilitate the pursuit of their strategies.
There are two main mechanisms by which climate change facilitates the rise and growth of NSAGs:
1. Climate change is increasingly contributing to fragility, in the analysed cases mainly by contributing to
conflicts surrounding natural resources and livelihood insecurity. NSAGs proliferate and can operate
more easily in these fragile and conflict-affected environments where the state has little to no authority
(‘ungoverned space’) and is lacking legitimacy. Sometimes, NSAGs also try to fill the gap left by the
state by providing basic services in order to gain legitimacy and secure trust and support among the
local population.
2. Climate change is having increasingly negative impacts on livelihoods in many countries and regions,
e.g. through food insecurity or water/land scarcities. This makes the affected population groups more
vulnerable not only to negative climate impacts but also to recruitment by NSAGs. These groups can
offer alternative livelihoods and economic incentives and/or respond to political and socio-economic
grievances.
Another interesting finding is the way NSAGs leverage the fragile environments arising from compound
climate-fragility risks:
3. NSAGs are increasingly using natural resources as a weapon of war. The case studies show that in
resource-scarce and fragile environments, NSAGs can use natural resources such as water as a
weapon of war or inhibit access to natural resources. This in turn further compounds and exacerbates
resource scarcities. This dynamic might be exacerbated as climate change increases the scarcity of
natural resources in certain regions of the world: the scarcer resources become, the more power is
given to those who control them.
Looking at the interplay between climate change, fragility and NSAGs, there is a risk that the feedback
loops and complex interactions create vicious cycles of increasing climate impacts, vulnerability, violence,
conflict and fragility. As the negative impacts of climate change increase and contribute to fragility, this
benefits NSAG, which leads to further destabilization and fragility, and increases vulnerability to the negative
impacts of climate change. These dynamics can be further exacerbated by using increasingly scarce
natural resources as a weapon.
In general, climate change will increasingly challenge the ability of states to deliver services and provide
stability. Extreme climate events, in particular, can strain the social fabric and the relationship between
governments and populations. While government responsiveness in the face of disasters can strengthen
the social contract, poor and slow responses are likely to weaken it, contributing to further instability and
feeding into the downward spiral of fragility, violence and vulnerability.
However, it is also important to emphasize that climate change is just one among many drivers of fragility
and conflict. Climate change acts as a threat multiplier and compounds other risks. Other important
drivers of fragility include ineffective responses by state security forces, a lack of traditional conflict
resolution mechanisms, a lack of government legitimacy, marginalization, religion, identity, and endemic
corruption.
Foreign policy makers have to play an active role in breaking the vicious cycle of increasing climate
impacts, vulnerability, violence, conflict and fragility and in preventing climate change contributing to an
environment in which NSAGs can thrive. However, action should be based on a thorough understanding
of the hybrid and complex nature of NSAGs and it needs to address the root causes of the rise and growth
of NSAGs.
In the political realm, there is a tendency to frame NSAGs primarily in the context of the war on terrorism.
However, these actors are much more complex and diverse. States are increasingly confronted with
NSAGs that blur the lines between intra- and interstate war, between traditional and non-traditional
conflict settings, between ideological, political and economic interests, and between armed conflict and
crime. Climate change combined with other pressures and stressors creates a specific context that is
conducive to the rise and growth of NSAGs.
Broadening the perspective and understanding the hybrid and complex nature of NSAGs, the motivations
that drive them, and the context in which they thrive is indispensable for adequately responding to the
security challenges they pose. A broader perspective will help to better address the root causes of the
rise and growth of NSAGs: While economic, social and political factors remain important, the environmental
dimension of fragility and conflict cannot be separated from the other three dimensions. An
overly narrow perspective on NSAGs and the misuse of the concept of ‘violent extremism’ “risks downplaying
other sources of fragility, delegitimizing political grievances and stigmatizing communities as
potential extremists” (Crisis Group 2016).
Based on this broad understanding, foreign policy makers can help to address the challenges of NSAGs
in a changing climate by supporting the building of more resilient states and societies. The key will be to
more effectively link climate change adaptation, development and humanitarian aid, and peace-building
and conflict prevention. The five action areas outlined in this report could serve as a starting point.
1. Ensuring the climate and conflict-sensitivity of interventions will be key to making sure that interventions
are less prone to failure, and are able to realize synergies and co-benefits. At present, like many
peacebuilding activities, interventions and strategies to counter violent extremism largely do not take
climate change into account.
2. Promoting good governance and strengthening local institutions may not traditionally fall under
climate change adaptation programming, but such activities are priorities in reducing the risk that
climate change presents to the rise and growth of NSAGs, as well as being a core component of
adaptation and peacebuilding writ large.
3. Creating sustainable livelihoods is both important to adapting to climate change and to preventing the
rise and growth of NSAGs. Peacebuilding, climate change adaptation and development impacts could
be achieved by focusing on climate-sensitive sectors such as agriculture and fisheries, and taking
specific account of the risks and opportunities associated with youth bulges and migration.
4. Improving disaster risk reduction can help to break the mutually reinforcing relationship between
fragility and disasters and prevent NSAGs abusing the weakness of the state. If underpinned by a plan
and political willingness, disasters and crises can also be used as opportunities to increase resilience
and not only rebuild better but also to increase legitimacy and even build peace.
5. Climate change and other risks and challenges, including NSAGs, often converge in cities. Resilient
cities are at the heart of resilient states and societies. It is important that the whole range of interventions
including climate change adaptation, disaster risk reduction, humanitarian aid, peacebuilding
and conflict prevention put a stronger focus on cities affected by fragility and conflict.
Broad and integrated approaches, however, are not a goal in themselves. They are processes that need to
engage people and their problems. Although there is a great potential for co-benefits and synergies,
integration also often brings with it trade-offs and the need for negotiating competing interests and goals
– a challenge foreign policy makers are well equipped to address.
to read full report please click on
Insurgency CLIMATE CHANGE REPORT
Share Your Comments
Only members can comment, Click here to sign up for free right now