Agricultural productivity and innovation
Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations
Rome, 2017
To meet demand, agriculture in 2050 will need to produce almost 50 percent more food, feed and biofuel than it did in 2012. This FAO estimate takes into account recent United Nations (UN) projections indicating that the world’s population would reach 9.73 billion in 2050.
1 In sub-Saharan Africa and South Asia, agricultural output would need to more than double by 2050 to meet increased demand, while in the rest of the world the projected increase would be about one-third above current levels (Table 5.1).
- The estimated increase to 2050 differs from AT2050’s projection of an increase of 60 percent (Alexandratos and Bruinsma,
2012). The updated figure here accounts for both the UN’s revised population projection and increases in production between 2005/07 (the previous base year) and 2012 (the new base year). Accounting only for the revised population projections, global agricultural demand is projected to increase by more than 63 percent between 2005/07 and 2050. Since production expanded by 15 percent between 2005/07 and 2012, the projected increase in agricultural demand from 2013 to 2050 would amount to approximately 49 percent.

Meeting the increased demand should not be a major challenge, if past achievements are a guide. Historically, much bigger increases in agricultural production have been recorded in comparable time frames. Between 1961 and 2011, global agricultural output more than tripled. In low-income coun-tries, livestock production has been one of the fastest growing agricultural subsectors. Since the early 1970s, per capita consumption of milk, dairy products and vegetable oils has almost doubled, while meat consumption has almost tripled (Alexandratos and Bruinsma, 2012).
Over the past five decades, per capita consumption of fish has more than doubled. Since the 1980s, virtually all of the increase in the amount of fish consumed has come from aquaculture, which has outpaced population growth and become the world’s fastest growing food production industry (FAO, 2016c).
However, owing to a range of factors, including climate change, pressure on natural resources, underinvestment in agriculture and gaps in tech-nology, maintaining the pace of production increases may be more difficult than in the past. For example, per capita fish consumption in Africa may shrink from 7.5 kg a year in 2006 to 5.6 kg a year by 2030, as the population is expected to grow more rapidly than supply (WFP, 2013, p. 45). Rapid technological development and innovation offers the prospect of meeting future food needs sustainably. However, this can only be achieved through discerning public policies, increased investments and public-private part-nerships, which exploit the opportunities for maintaining current levels of productivity, sustainably raising yields, and reducing poverty and food insecurity.
Yield increases are slowing, despite overall improvements in agricultural efficiency
Increased use of land, irrigation and agro-chemicals played a major role in the growth of agricultural production during the Green Revolution. However, it is now recognized that the gains were often accompanied by negative effects on agriculture’s natural resource base, including land degradation, salinization of irrigated areas, over-extraction of groundwater, the build-up of pest resistance and the erosion of biodiversity. Agriculture has also damaged the wider environment through deforestation, the emission of greenhouse gases and nitrate pollution of water bodies (FAO, 2011a).
Since the 1990s, average annual increases in the yields of maize, rice, and wheat at the global level have been slightly more than 1 percent, much lower than in the 1960s (Figure 5.1), while those of soybeans and sugarcane have been below 1 percent. Because the substantial additional amounts of food needed in coming decades will be produced mainly through yield increases, rather than major expansion of the cultivated area, cereal yield growth rates below 1 percent a year would be a worrying signal.
2 There are also very large differences in crop yields between high-income and low-in-come countries (Table 5.2). Yields of wheat and rice in low-income countries are currently about half those in high-income countries.
- Cereal production would need to increase from 2.068 billion tonnes in 2005–07 to 3.009 in 2050, a 43.4 percent increase (Alexandratos and Bruinsma, 2012). The assumption that 80 percent of this increase should come from yield increases implies that yields should increase by around
- percent by 2050, i.e. in 34 years. This translates into an annual growth rate of 0.9 percent.

Note: Calculations based on FAOSTAT production statistics (downloaded on 20 September 2016). Growth rates estimated using the ordinary least squares (OLS) regression of the natural logarithm of crop yields on time and a constant term. The commodity group ‘Cereals (total)’ is from FAOSTAT and includes: wheat, rice (paddy), barley, maize, rye oats, millet, sorghum, buckwheat, quinoa, fonio, triticale, canary seed, as well as grains and mixed cereals not elsewhere specified.
Yields of major crops (cereals, roots and tubers, pulses, sugar crops, oil crops and vegetables) also vary substantially across regions. Estimated yield gaps, expressed as a percentage of potential yields, exceed 50 percent in most low-income countries. They are largest in sub-Saharan Africa (76 percent) and lowest in East Asia (11 percent). The gap between farm yields and potential yields reflects constraints, such as insufficient adoption of more productive technologies, a lack of market integration and gender inequalities in small-scale family farming (FAO, 2011b).
The productivity of aquaculture has been increasing, owing to the intensification of production methods. In Asia, small-scale traditional pond aquaculture, in which a range of carp species with complementary feeding behaviours were stocked in fertilized ponds, has given way to farmed fish and crustacean production that is heavily, if not exclusively, reliant on feeds. Key drivers have been rising land prices and the high prices paid for farmed fish, which makes feeds affordable (Beveridge
et al., 2013).
Resource-conserving practices are helping to increase agricultural productivity
The key to sustainable agricultural growth is more efficient use of land, labour and other inputs through technological progress, social innovation and new business models. For agriculture and aquaculture to respond to future challenges, innovation will not only need to improve the efficiency with which inputs are turned into outputs, but also conserve scarce natural resources and reduce waste (OECD, 2011; Troell
et al., 2014). The farming practices required to conserve and make more efficient use of natural resources will differ according to local conditions and needs.
Recent years have seen a growing trend towards the adoption of conser-vation agriculture. This approach seeks to reduce soil disturbance by minimizing mechanical tillage, maintain a protective organic cover on the soil surface, and cultivate a wider range of plant species – both annuals and perennials – in associations, sequences and rotations that may include trees, shrubs, pastures and crops. It promotes, for example, the integration into cropping systems of pulses and legumes that help build up and maintain soil nitrogen levels.
Worldwide, conservation agriculture has been adopted on some 117 million ha, or about 8 percent of total world cropland. The highest adop-tion levels – above 50 percent of cropland – are found in Australia, Canada and the southern cone of South America. Adoption has been low in Africa, Central Asia and China, but it is increasing (FAO, 2011a). However, high levels of dis-adoption have also been observed, underscoring the need for a nuanced approach that takes into account different factors, such as the effects of climate change, as well as barriers to adoption (Arslan
et al., 2013; Grabowski
et al., 2016; IAPRI, 2016).
Agroecology represents a shift from ‘ready-to-use’ to ‘custom-made’ production systems. Farmers achieve a greater quality and quantity of production by transitioning from a reliance on chemical inputs to a holistic, integrated approach based on ecosystem management. This is done by re-introducing biological complexity, particularly by increasing plant diversity, perennial cover and the presence of trees. By closing the nitrogen cycle, agroecological farming improves the efficiency of food production and provides a number of environmental co-benefits, including reduced waste and pollution at landscape level and increased economic efficiency at farm level (FAO, 2015).
Climate-smart agriculture aims at sustainably increasing food security and incomes, and adapting and building resilience to climate change, while capturing potential mitigation co-benefits. It connects other inno-vations, such as conservation agriculture, agroecology, agroforestry and the development of crop varieties that are more tolerant to pests, diseases, drought, waterlogging and salinity (FAO, 2013). More than 30 countries in sub-Saharan Africa explicitly referred to climate-smart agriculture in their Intended Nationally Determined Contributions, which aim at reducing GHGs emissions and were prepared for the 21st Conference of the Parties of United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, held in Paris in December 2015.
Climate-smart agriculture has promoted mixed crop-livestock systems and sustainable livestock production, which integrate environmental and production objectives through, for example, the rotation of pasture and forage crops to enhance soil quality and reduce erosion, and the use of livestock manure to maintain soil fertility. In climate-smart agriculture, agroforestry systems are an important means of sustainably producing food while conserving ecosystems, especially in marginal areas prone to environmental degradation.
In the fisheries and aquaculture sectors, ‘blue growth’ approaches focus on improving productivity and performance through climate-resilient systems.
3 Opportunities for blue growth encompass improved marine and freshwater fisheries systems, aquaculture, aquaponics and other forms of The future of food and agriculture · Trends and challenges combined aquaculture/agriculture production. Blue growth approaches also offer opportunities for innovation in production environments where agriculture is not possible, such as brackish water and saline systems. This will be particularly useful in countries where climate change adaptation will focus on building resilience and improving disaster risk management in marine waters and coastal areas, and addressing the multiple stresses on inland waters.
The adoption of improved agricultural practices would contribute to increased total factor productivity (TFP) in agriculture. TFP refers to increases in agricultural output owing to an overall increase of efficiency of production processes, rather than through the intensification of input use. Globally, TFP growth accounted for about 40 percent of production increases between 1961 and 2010 (Figure 5.2). It has become increasingly important over time, with growth averaging around 2 percent per year since 2000. In high-income countries, TFP growth has been the main contributor to increases in agricultural output. While output in low-income countries has increased mainly through the expansion of agricultural areas, over the last decade TFP growth has increased significantly (USDA, 2016).

farming operations and increased efficiency of input use. In the longer term, mechanization would support the sustainable intensification of production systems and help to build an agriculture sector that is more resilient to increasingly extreme and unpredictable climatic events.
In countries with a large proportion of small family farms, promoting innovation that leads to higher TFP growth is essential for ensuring produc-tive and sustainable agriculture. Similar arguments apply to aquaculture. In the long run, productivity growth in agriculture as a whole requires continuous technological progress, as well as social innovations and new business and investment models.
There is widespread awareness that the adoption and adaptation of sustainable farming systems and practices, such as conservation agricul-ture, agroforestry, integrated crop-livestock-energy systems and integrated pest management, require technological innovation and investment in research and development (R&D). Investment is also needed to implement and support new organizational forms of R&D that are closer to farmers’ needs, as highlighted for instance through the experiences of farmer field schools (FAO and INRA, 2016; European Commission, 2007). Last, but not least, an institutional enabling environment is crucial to ensure the effec-tive implementation of sustainable farming systems and to support their promotion and adoption.
After a period of stagnation, agricultural R&D is surging
Following a decade of slowing growth in the 1990s, global expenditure on agricultural R&D increased by an average of 3.1 percent a year during the period 2000–2009 (Table 5.3), rising from US$25 billion to US$33.6 billion. Spending by China and India accounted for close to half of the increase. Argentina, Brazil, Iran, Nigeria, and the Russian Federation also signifi-cantly increased their spending on public agricultural R&D, and collectively accounted for one-fifth of the total increase in spending worldwide. Among low-income countries, annual R&D spending grew by 2.3 percent, driven largely by increases in Ethiopia, Kenya, Uganda and the United Republic of Tanzania.
A commonly used indicator of a country’s agricultural research efforts is ‘agricultural research intensity’ (ARI), which indicates national public expenditure on agricultural R&D as a share of agricultural gross domestic product (GDP). While there is no ‘right’ level of ARI, overall government R&D expenditure for science and technology of at least 1 percent of national GDP has been recommended (ECOSOC, 2004). For the agriculture sector, countries in both the low-income and the lower middle-income groups are generally far below this target, although there are major differences within the groups (Figure 5.3).
Private investment in R&D increased from US$12.9 billion in 1994 to US$18.2 billion in 2008 (Beintema
et al., 2012). Global private investment in R&D in agriculture and food processing accounted for about 21 percent of total R&D expenditures in 2008. Almost all private research takes place in high-income countries. However, it has grown in India (Pray and Nagarajan, 2012) and China (Pal, Rahija and Beintema, 2012), where it accounts, respec-tively, for 19 percent and 16 percent of total agricultural R&D spending
Note: Simple average of annual agricultural research intensity (ARI), measured as the ratio of public expenditure on agricultural R&D to agricultural GDP.
(excluding food processing). No such figures are available for aquaculture. Until recently, private agricultural R&D was concentrated in the machinery and chemical sectors. There has been a recent surge in private investment in the life sciences, driven partly by changes to the governance of intellec-tual property rights for biological innovations (Wright and Pardey, 2006).
Estimates of the rates of return to agricultural R&D suggest it has a very high social value. Estimated annual internal rates of return on investments on agricultural R&D range between 20 percent and 80 percent (Alston, 2010). In low-income countries, the dollar-for-dollar impact of R&D investments on the value of agricultural production is generally within the range of 6 to 12 percent (Fan, Yu and Saurkar, 2008; Fan and Zhang, 2008; FAO, 2012).
Citizen resistance to GMOs risks overshadowing the contribution of other biotechnologies
Agricultural biotechnology, defined as ‘any technological application that uses biological systems, living organisms, or derivatives thereof, to make or modify products or processes for specific use’ (CBD, 2013) can make a significant contribution to productive and sustainable agriculture. Biotechnologies range from low-tech approaches, such as artificial insemi-nation, fermentation techniques and biofertilizers, to high-tech approaches and advanced DNA-based methods, such as genetically modified organisms (GMOs).
A major, and polarizing, debate about GMOs has been underway since the 1990s.
4 This debate revolves around their potential impacts on food security, the environment, biodiversity, human and animal health, and control of the global food system. It is claimed that genetic modification can help, in some circumstances, to increase production and productivity.
5 However, GMOs raise concerns about potential risks to human and animal health and to the environment. Potential risks and benefits need to be carefully evaluated on a case-by-case basis.
One unfortunate consequence of this long-running debate is that the achievements of other biotechnologies have been overshadowed. For example, New Rice for Africa (NERICA) varieties have been developed using biotechnologies that enable African and Asian species of cultivated rice to be crossed. NERICA varieties, which combine the high yields of Asian rice with the ability of African rice to thrive in harsh environments, are now widely distributed in sub-Saharan Africa.
6 Adoption of such ‘biotech crops’ is the most pronounced crop technology trend of recent years (James, 2014). Another example is the current development in China of perennial rice, which is capable of re-growing season after season without need for reseeding.
Investment patterns in biotechnology R&D are highly uneven. China’s budget for agricultural biotechnology is 10 times that of Brazil and India, but those two countries vastly out-spend the whole of sub-Saharan Africa. Since most new biotechnologies have been developed outside low-income countries, improved North-South links that facilitate capacity building and technology flow are crucial. The lack of adequate and sustained investments remains a major limitation in most low-income countries. Moreover, many biotechnology products, such as new crop varieties, have been developeped.
- In aquaculture, the only genetically modified farmed fish, the AquAdvantage Atlantic salmon, attains market size in 16 to 18 months, rather than three years. However, critics argue that because aquaculture remains largely based on the rearing of fish that differ little from wild relatives, there is much to be gained from application of conventional selective breeding, without resorting to technologies whose risks are not fully understood and which produces a product with unproven public acceptance.
- A comprehensive global meta-analysis of 147 published biotech crop studies over the last 20 years worldwide found that on average GMO technology adoption has reduced chemical pesticide use by 37 percent, increased crop yields by 22 percent, and increased farmer profits by 68 percent (Klümper and Qaim, 2014). In 2014, GMO crops were grown in
- countries on 181.5 million ha, up from 1.7 million ha in 1996
- million farmers grow GMO crops, including 14.8 million farmers in China and India.
- The above heavily borrows from the web site of the International Symposium on ‘The role of biotechnologies in sustainable food systems and nutrition’ (available at www.fao. org/about/meetings/agribiotechs-symposium/faqs/en) (FAO, 2016b).
The future of food and agriculture · Trends and challenges by private sector companies, which have no explicit commitment to public goods. To facilitate the uptake of agricultural biotechnologies and improved non-commercial staple crops in low-income countries, without compro-mising the processes that lead to innovation, public-private partnerships are making the products of existing biotechnologies available to smallholders in areas where the private sector has little commercial interest.
Nanotechnology also offers opportunities for innovation. Already, nanotechnology-based food and health food products, and food packaging materials, are available in some countries, and it is expected that they will be increasingly available to consumers worldwide in the coming years (FAO and WHO, 2010). However, despite the numerous potential advantages of nanotechnology, agricultural applications have not yet made it to the market. The main factors limiting the development of these applications are low levels of investment in workforce training and research infrastructure (Parisi, Vigani and Rodríguez-Cerezo, 2015).
Citizen resistance to biotechnology and nanotechnology, as well as fears of commercial losses, have also played a significant role in limiting the use and spread of these technologies. These trends are found across the world (David and Thompson, 2008; Gruère and Sengupta, 2009; Aerni and Bernauer, 2006; Fairfield-Sonn, 2016; Stilgoe, Owen and Macnaghten, 2013). Recent policy emphasis on responsible research and innovation may help to improve citizen-science dialogues around the introduction of new and emerging technologies (Stilgoe, Owen and Macnaghten, 2013).
Mobile phones and farmer field schools also contribute to agricultural innovation
Information and communications technologies are playing an increasingly important role in keeping farmers and rural entrepreneurs informed about agricultural innovations, weather conditions, input availability, financial services and market prices, and connecting them with buyers. Mobile phones have great potential for promoting inclusiveness. They allow fishers and aquaculture producers, for example, to market their perishable produce more effectively and command better prices as a result. Mobile phone subscriber penetration stands at almost 60 percent in low-income countries, and is still growing rapidly. By 2020, more than 90 percent of the incremental 1 billion new mobile subscribers are forecast to be in low- and middle-income countries (GSMA, 2016). Mobile phones shorten the distance between previously isolated smallholders and other actors involved in producing, processing, transporting, marketing, and regulating food (Conway, 2016). They can also speed up the supply of inputs through e-vouchers and real-time tracking of inventory.
Face-to-face extension services are being complemented, and sometimes replaced, by mobile phones, the Internet and more conventional media, such as radio, video and television. In many countries, extension services have evolved away from top-down ‘technology transfer’ to participatory and discovery-based approaches that inspire innovation. Farmer field schools support farmers in building their technical and organizational skills, adapting technologies to local needs and blending them with local knowledge. The farmer field schools approach has spread to more than 90 countries and has been used to train an estimated 20 million farmers. Action research involving farmers, scientists, rural advisors and non-governmental organ-izations (NGOs), as well as farmer-researcher networks, have also had significant success.
The reduction in public extension services has been accompanied by growth in private sector dissemination of technologies and practices. Despite the growing importance of private services, for both economic and social reasons, there is still a clear need in many countries for governments to maintain a role in providing advice to farmers (Compagnone, Goulet and Labarthe, eds., 2015). Creating closer linkages between R&D and extension, particularly using farmer-led research and other learning-based approaches, has proved an effective means of expanding the adaptation and adoption of technology (Darnhofer, Gibbon and Dedieu, 2012).
The application and dissemination of technologies is changing. Although they present opportunities for raising productivity and meeting new chal-lenges, they also carry the risk of aggravating disparities between high-in-come countries and countries with the highest rates of hunger and poverty. Because public and private investment in R&D is concentrated in high-in-come countries and a few emerging countries, the growing importance of biotechnology means that yield gaps for lower-income countries are likely to widen further.
Ownership of new technologies by the private sector often restricts their diffusion in countries that are already least able to afford them, but where the benefits could be substantial. This underscores the importance of regu-lation and the strengthening of providers of public goods, such as the CGIAR and regional and national agricultural research systems. Public intervention is required for R&D in support of resource-conserving approaches, such as conservation agriculture and climate-smart agriculture, which may attract limited private investment.
Source :FAO. 2017. The future of food and agriculture – Trends and challenges. Rome.
Share Your Comments
Only members can comment, Click here to sign up for free right now