Transboundary river basin management in Europe
Andrea M. Keessen, Jasper J.H. van Kempen & Helena F.M.W. van Rijswick*
1. Introduction
Modern water policy is shaped by geographical areas in the context of which water courses are divided into river basins. This is reflected on an international level by treaties such as the 1992 Convention on the Protection and Use of Transboundary Watercourses and International lakes (the Helsinki Convention),1 and at the European level by the Water Framework Directive (the WFD)2 and the Floods Directive.3 An interesting feature of modern water law, particularly on a European level, is that it aims to achieve a specific ‘status.’ This implies that ground water and surface water in the river basin should be in a certain ‘good status’ under the WFD, while the Floods Directive stipulates that flood risks should be manageable in order to reduce the risk as well as the consequences of a flood for humans, the environment, cultural heritage and the economy.4 The obligations arising from the European water directives are, in principle, aimed at a certain result to be achieved by each individual Member State.5 Due to the transboundary nature of water management, these objectives can only be achieved, however, if the parties located in a transnational river basin (EU Member States and non-Member States) cooperate. The combination of, on the one hand, the geographical area approach which requires Member States to cooperate (even with third countries, if need be) and, on the other, objectives that have to be met by each Member State individually, leads to a fragile balance as a result of which it is not clear whether Member States can be held responsible for not achieving the objectives due to reasons over which they do not have complete control.

To put it differently: Member States can manage water that fails to meet the quality requirements without this failure being (completely) attributable to events taking place on their own territory.6 There may be several reasons why a Member State is not able to meet its own obligations arising from a water directive. One can think in this context of international cooperation within a river basin that does not achieve the intended results in time, and particularly regarding the WFD one also can think of the inability of EU Member States to take the measures required in other policy fields because they lack the adequate powers to do so (agricultural policy, fisheries policy, admission of products for e.g. medicinal products and pesticides). In the latter case (lack of adequate powers) it means that Member States have to rely on initiatives taken by Community institutions.7 The WFD does not provide for an exemption in these cases, and neither does the Floods Directive.8 This means that it is doubtful whether a Member State will be able to defend itself by (partly) shifting the blame onto another (Member) State. After all, a Member State is responsible for its own waters. As the new water directives, and the WFD in particular, focus primarily on the achievement of a specific objective, it is of the utmost importance to know exactly which possibilities are available to central or decentralised government bodies in order to meet these obligations in cases of transboundary water pollution or increased flood risk.
This article addresses the legal instruments which Member States and (decentralised) water authorities have at their disposal in this respect to meet their European obligations and thus shape transboundary river basin management. First of all, we will discuss aspects of transboundary cooperation aimed at combating transboundary water pollution and floods within river basins, including instruments to create such cooperation (Section 2) and ways of effectively implementing this cooperation (Section 3). Subsequently (Section 4), the article will address the remedies Member States and decentralised water authorities have at their disposal to enforce the said cooperation, ranging from international dispute settlements (Section 4.1) to European procedures (Section 4.2) and domestic administrative procedures (Section 4.3).
to read full article please click on
Transboundary_River_Basin_Management
Share Your Comments
Only members can comment, Click here to sign up for free right now