WATER PEACE AT HOME WATER PEACE IN THE WORLD

General

Innovative Hydropolitics is Needed Between Malawi and Mozambique

Dursun Yıldız Director of Hydropolitics Association 8 March  2016 Introduction    Throughout history, nations have generally focused on  how to share the transboundary river discharges. New developments force the nations to share cost and benefits of the river on the basis of river basin.The key issue here has always been and remains to be the development of new Hydro Diplomacy. If water more often unites than divides people and societies then we can find the best suitable way to get increasing risk and threat out. The major task, which the international community is facing today in the field of water resources, is the transfer of committed obligations into concrete actions that need Shifting Paradigm from classical cooperation to real collaboration. Shifting Paradigm And Conceptional Change  Conceptualizing conflict and cooperation in a linear fashion is not a solution-oriented approach. It is very hard to achieve transboundary water cooperation with normative assumptions starting from existing conflicted water issues. Therefore it needs a new conceptual approach. It may be productive to focus on the analyses of rapid changing which brought new areas to collaborate between basin states rather than taking discrete events related to transboundary water interactions. We can say that “Traditional Water Conflict or Cooperation” concept ends with integrated approach with an emphasis on increased diversity and flexibility is needed. It is because of that numerous challenges are involved in water management. These various challenges call for multifaceted, more flexible hydro policy processes. We need to shift the transboundary water management approach from Water Cooperation to Collaboration to achieve one step ahead to water related goals and security issues as soon as possible Concerns over transboundary water "cooperation" has to shift away from absolute water quantity to applicable benefit sharing collaboration on water supply. If collaboration is essential in sustainable transboundary water management, a mutually beneficial way can help built this collaboration in appropriate transboundary river basins. Most of the developments including climate change and nexus water ,energy,food and ecosystem showed that a vital need is growing to get innovative approaches to transboundary water governance. We should develop very innovative approach to transboundary water governance in various basins of the 13 Fig 1. Malawi and Mozambique map World. First of all we should downscale the concepts and principles of international treaties and regulations on water to a very local level. We should take into account that multilevel governance considering the balance between them. If building trust between the riparian countries is a must. Then we should find a new and innovative approach and more interdependent relationship apart from classical “cooperation“ approach to built dependable and sustainable trust. 12 The Shire catchment. The Shire catchment comprises one portion of the broader Zambezi Basin and forms part of the Lower Zambezi Basin, which together covers Lake Malawi and the Shire River system (Figure 1). The Shire River originates as an outlet at the southern edge of Lake Malawi and flows 415 km. southwards where it joins the Zambezi River. As flows into Lake Malawi are currently unregulated and the effect of decision making upstream of the lake outlet is estimated to be minimal, focus was placed on the Shire catchment downstream of the lake(Figure 2).. The catchment covers an area of approximately 49,000 km2, generating a mean annual runoff of approximately 15.7 km3. Of its coverage, 35,000 km2 is in Malawi and 14,000 km2 in Mozambique; hence, approximately 71% of the catchment is in Malawi and 29% in Mozambique. More than 4 million people live in the river’s catchment; approximately 3.6 million in Malawi and approximately 0.6 million in Mozambique (IWMI 2015). Existing Condition   The level of collaboration between Malawi and Mozambique on water issues is currently limited. At a broader Zambezi Basin level, Malawi and Mozambique cooperate within the framework of the Southern African Development Community (SADC) Water Resources Technical Committee. Some cooperation is also achieved through the Zambezi Watercourse Commission (ZAMCOM), of which Angola, Botswana, Mozambique, Namibia, Tanzania, Zambia and Zimbabwe are member states. Malawi has not yet ratified this agreement, but nonetheless participates as an observer(IWMI 2015).. Discussions with personnel at relevant water authorities, including Administração Regional de Águas do Zambeze (ARA-Zambeze) in Mozambique and the Shire River Basin Management Programme in Malawi, were conducted to identify priority transboundary water issues. Results of the discussions suggest four key water issues of transboundary importance: flooding, aquatic weeds (water hyacinth), navigation and future water infrastructure development . The importance of flooding was manifested in conclusion of the Agreement on the Establishment of the Joint Water Commission (2003), which was signed in response to the devastating floods in 2001. The importance of navigation is reflected in The Feasibility Study for the Navigability of ShireZambezi Waterways supported by the African Development Bank (AfDB). 11 Photo 1. Shire River What to do to achieve meaningful collaboration In order  to achieve meaningful collaboration win win is the best model in many case. It should be used a  gradational levels of cooperation on water issues.  It would be wise to  focuse on the establishment of a joint committee. This committee  can serve as a platform for data exchange and research on the issues of flooding . After a  confidence building time the commite agenda can be extended to work on  aquatic weed management and rules for navigation.When the committee reach a mutually agreement to tka further step for adoptation ,this could be second phase of the gradually varied establishment of the collaboration . In this stage to reach an agreement on a joint taxation and maintenance program for navigation could be possible. Next step would be an action stage that focuse on on the construction, operation and maintenance of joint infrastructure work. During this muttualy understanding period ,an acceptable and appliacble  cost sharing  model  should be negosiated for any infrastructure or river maintenance programs  It is important to  find ways for riparian countries to satisfy each other’s interests for mutual benefit instead of zero sum result. For example, upstream areas of Malawi could incorporate downstream areas of Mozambique more concretely into flood planning and management activities. In return, Mozambique could offer concessions to Malawian vessels that wish to navigate from Nsanje to the Indian Ocean (and vice versa) (IWMI). 2015. As for specific, constructive ways forward in the Shire catchment,it can be started with small steps and low intensity.After a certain period of time , confidence building  can identify the best opportunity for upscaling.  Respective riparian advantages and interests can be a cataliser to reach muttualy benefical collaboration point.After this stage it can be  utilized adaptive  approaches to find most appropirate way of application . The mechanism will be used   through  all stages diverge from conventional approaches often used. Main goal is to reach an active collaboration on water related issues with  spill over effects on different sectors .Global norms can supply theoretical  very large frames  but  contextual realities may lie at  scales other than the basin wide or regional wide  approachs.  Conclusions Gained experiences have shown that there is a lot to do in transboundary surface and groundwater basin management. Radical change in way of thinking is a must in transboundary basin management. Therefore what to do first is simply accepting that "It needs more then cooperation" anymore. There is also a need to move from the global analysis (which is very useful to quantify the problem) to localized and contextualized solutions that involve local partners. One solution definitely doesn‟t fit all. Participants concluded that during the past years there has been positive progress in awareness, knowledge and tools development but there is a need to advance on policy coherence and sectorial planning. Climate change progressively became a security issue for the countries, leading to a necessary change of water policies as well as their behavior to transboundary water management. It should therefore be a priority to promote deeper cooperation, comprehensive collaboration on transboundary water management in assessing climate change and its impacts on these strategical water resources. In fact, classical cooperation approach between co-riparian states wouldn't be enough to manage the Transboundary Rivers and transboundary aquifers under the effects of climate change as well as new international relationships and new geopolitics. Besides the Transboundary Rivers, the proper governance of transboundary aquifers requires particularly high levels of international collaboration. Sustainable transboundary water management need greater political and diplomatic engagement that can't be achieved only classical cooperative approach on water issues. It requires shared vision, shared goal and unity of effort which means a real collaborative approach on the basis of new Hydro-diplomacy approach instead of tight classical cooperative  one. International water issues  need  more then Cooperation. Instead of  entire  basin-scale focus , basin-scale with a focus on scales inside the basin is an innovative and goal oriented method to reach solutions. Solutions to certain water issues such as  dam operation, flood prevention, pollution control  may be easier other than the full basin management. Management frameworks at scales within basins may no doubt need to be navigated carefully.Nonetheless, focus on a selective part of a basin may constitute more achievable or ‘second best’ forms of water management that may foster practical progress.As it is  stated  in IWMI Water Policy Brief  No:39 , we shouldn’t  overlook focus on practical issues to achieve practical progress. In conclusion, it would seem that   a full basin scale cooperation  , in recent decades, can be associated with an increase in softer, more politicized and arguably more precarious cooperation—reflected in the number of RBOs struggling to secure riparian funding. It would equally appear that meaningful, practicallyoriented water cooperation occurs at more local scales. While ultimately good water management is likely to require harmonization of basin and local developments, it seems that building  on momentum at the local level  deserves more attention in order  to improve relations on transboundary  water management References De Bruyne, C.; Lautze, J.; Kazbekov. J. In prep. Developing fit-for-purpose transboundary water cooperation: Options for the Shire catchment. In: The Zambezi Basin: Pathways for sustainable development, eds., Lautze, J.; Cai, X.; Wishart, M.; Phiri, Z. Earthscan. (In preparation). Giordano, M.; Drieschova, A.; Duncan, J.A.; Sayama, Y.; De Stefano, L.; Wolf, A.T. 2014. A review of the evolution and state of transboundary freshwater treaties. International Environmental Agreements: Politics, Law and Economics 14(3): 245-264. INBO (International Network of Basin Organizations); GWP (Global Water Partnership). 2012. The handbook for integrated water resources management in transboundary basins of rivers, lakes and aquifers. International Water Management Institute (IWMI). 2015. Thinking inside the basin: scale in transboundary water management. Colombo, Sri Lanka: International Water Management Institute (IWMI). 8p. (IWMI Water Policy Brief 39). doi: 10.5337/2015.222 Sadoff, C.; Grey, D. 2005. Cooperation on international rivers: A continuum for securing and sharing benefits. Water International 30(4): 420-427. Sadoff, C.; Greiber, T.; Smith, M.; Bergkamp, G. 2008. Share: Managing water across boundaries. Gland, Switzerland: International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Publication Services. Yıldız. D., 2015 “International Water Issues Need More Than Cooperation”World Scientific News WSN 12 (2015) 70-80 . EISSN 2392-2192 Zeitoun, M.; Mirumachi, N. 2008. Transboundary water interaction I: Reconsidering conflict and cooperation. International Environmental Agreements 8(4): 297-316.    
Share Your Comments

Only members can comment, Click here to sign up for free right now

(Your e-mail address will not be published)
Submit Review
No Comments Yet